Skip to content
Daily Classic Hub

The Vision to Overhaul the Academy Structure and Help Youth Footballers

One of the favourite moments of this season came recently, watching a young player break forward from his defensive box to score a decisive strike.

Young players are invariably appreciated by their club's supporters and, judging by early glimpses, the faithful are going to experience many more special displays from him in the time to come.

But, for each player who makes it, there are thousands of other boys and girls who are not successful beyond the myriad stages, and must face a devastating rejection at a tender age.

It is this group who drop out of youth football that I am concerned about, because I believe the present framework does enough to educate them about their odds, or support them when they are discarded.

It demands an overhaul and, after I left management, I put together my own report into the youth development pathway, with proposals for how it could be improved.

An Massive Outlay – With Certain Major Rewards

The viewpoint on academies is more than as a former manager. My family members are in the programme, so I've got a vested stake too.

For all aspiring footballers, the aspiration of becoming a professional player is a powerful one. The youth development framework has been put in place to give them the greatest chance to achieve that ambition, with a formal initiative being introduced over a decade ago.

Presently, over twelve thousand of boys are in the system, at teams from the highest division down. It's an all-encompassing set-up, with coaching no less than three nights a week and a games programme that occupies most of their weekends.

The same programme is now being used by the fastest-growing sport, girls football, too.

These setups are staffed at exceptional levels and provide work for coaches, physios, doctors and many more backroom staff.

The infrastructure are of the highest level, with top-class indoor and outdoor fields. Education is offered too, with tutors employed to run mandatory academic programmes.

The investment is immense but, as we have witnessed, the clubs at the top end are securing substantial returns on that outlay through loans and transfers of the young players.

How is the Existing Framework?

The key development plan has been in effect for around 15 years now, so how has it performed to the passage of time?

Academies now run a pre-academy programme for youngsters from the age of six, so if any of them see through the entire programme they would graduate at 21. That's more time than a child spends in compulsory school, and covers his entire childhood.

These children are provided with team uniform and jackets, all badged up, and are recognised by peers and family as being part of that club.

Their identity has, in essence, been etched on them at a young age and they also have to make a full commitment to the academy regime.

That means training on three evenings a week, and a games schedule lasting most of the weekend, are now integral to a young player's journey to follow his dream.

From my experiences, in a lot of cases what happens at their studies is seen as being secondary, with the academy taking over and evolving into the main preoccupation of the child and his family's life.

Some families see a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow if their child succeeds and heap tremendous expectation on their shoulders to make it.

Unfortunately, data show the system has a total disparity of achievement and failure. We all see the stars, but we seldom acknowledge those who are released.

Be Realistic About Their Odds

I don't want to remove those aspirations away from aspiring players but we have to be pragmatic with them about their prospects.

While there are specific individuals a club will pinpoint as being future professionals, the truth is many of the players have only been on the pathway to fill the positions needed for practice and the weekend matches at each age group.

I really believe academies sufficiently set the understandings of these players or guardians, about where they rank in the overall process.

Players and parents need to be given a full breakdown of where they rate, so they can manage for the likely disappointment when it occurs.

Our academies have produced some outstanding players and there is increased attention paid to player care now than in the past, but let's also incorporate a bit more focus on transparency too.

More Priority on Schooling

As I mentioned above, I think many youngsters joining academies actually listen more closely of their trainers at times than they do of their schoolteachers.

It's vital this is understood within the academy system, and youth directors impart this message to the coaches at every age group.

This phenomenon itself is nothing new. Mentoring played a significant part in my youth, and sports teachers and coaches were always held in high respect.

But, for anyone running an academy, they must ensure the coaches are given explicit direction and awareness of their responsibility because of the impact they have.

Levels of decorum, discipline and dedication should be as demanding as they are in any educational environment – and should apply to the academic side of the child's life there too.

The framework I have put forward would have greater weight on academics and guidance – for families as well as the young players – and also planning for what follows if they are let go aged 16.

The Blueprint to Assist Youth Players

I would place academies within several geographical areas, each managed by a director and align them with approved schools and colleges.

Prior to they get to apprenticeship level, players would be assessed at 14 to see what academic pathway suits them.

At 16, players starting scholarships would register in a compulsory dual education programme with the educational partners.

Simultaneously, the players who are released at 16, can begin a full-on combined learning programme with the schools or colleges.

The benefit for them would be the creation of a independent games programme where the schools and colleges would

About the author

Tom Hayes

A historian and writer passionate about uncovering timeless lessons from the past to enrich contemporary life.

Daily Classic Hub

Type to search articles.